in: Wellness

The Optimist-Pessimist Split: Why There Are Actually Benefits for Both


Half-full? Half-empty? The Care2 crew opens our eyes to some amazing benefits no matter which end of the optimist-pessimist spectrum you find yourself on.

Good news, optimists: your glass-half-full attitude has some major benefits to your health and happiness, just as you cheerily always assumed would be the case. Pessimist? Before you grumble “I knew it,” read on—there’s a bright side to always looking on the overcast side… unfortunately.

Pessimists have better relationships.

Optimist couples may seem disgustingly happy with each other all the time, but it’s pessimists who may actually have stronger relationships. Research suggests that optimism can be a “liability” in relationships, keeping couples from being pro-active when it comes to problem-solving. One study even found that couples who force themselves to stay optimistic during a rough spot in their marriages are doing more harm than good. Pessimists, on the other hand, have low expectations going into a marriage and experience more success and satisfaction as a result.

Optimists have better heart health.

Optimists have twice the odds of being in ideal cardiovascular health, according to an 11-year study of over 5,000 adults. They also had better blood sugar levels and cholesterol. No wonder they’re so cheery all the time.

Pessimists may live longer.

Heart health aside, there may still be a silver lining in never looking for the silver lining, at least according to one study of 40,000 Germans—pessimists who underestimated their future life satisfaction actually had a smaller risk of death within the 10-year study than optimists did. “Perceiving a dark future may foster positive evaluations of the actual self and may contribute to taking improved precautions,” the researchers wrote.

Optimists are more resilient.

Not only do optimists look on the bright side, they’re also likely to bounce back more quickly than pessimists. It’s not because they’re delusional, researchers say. Rather, they have a “growth mind-set”—instead of believing that a negative event (say, dropping the ball at a job interview) is a reflection of themselves, they believe that their abilities can be developed.

Pessimists can be more persuasive.

Working on a job application? Ask your most pessimistic friend to help you with your cover letter. Researchers have found that they may be better at delivering a persuasive message than optimists, thanks to a different informative processing style.

Optimists have better immune systems.

A positive attitude may strengthen the immune system, according to a study of 124 law students as they experience classes, tests, and internships. As optimism experienced a boost, immunity did too. And as optimism dropped, the immune system weakened.

Pessimists make more responsible decisions.

Optimism may lead to making riskier decisions, according to The Atlantic. Blame it on optimism bias, “the flawed reasoning that one has lower-than-average odds of experiencing negative events,” writer Lindsay Abrams explains. “Not wearing a bike helmet increases the risk of injury or death in the event of an accident, but it’s human for helmet-eschewers to believe that their personal risk is less than that of other, helmet-less riders.”


Written by Diana Vilibert

This article was originally published with Care2; republished with permission.

[image: via Bailey Weaver on flickr]

About the Author:

Care2 Care2

With over 25 million members, Care2 is the largest online community empowering people to take action on important causes and inspiring people to lead healthier, more sustainable lives. Visit today! Follow us onFacebook and Twitter.



Get Started: Sign up for Free

MeetMindful is a curated meeting ground for mindful and meaningful connections. Register for free and get started today (no card required).

No, thanks. I'm not single.